ClaudeSuperPower

review-hog-validation-criteria

Skill

The validation criteria for ReviewHog — the bar for deciding whether a flagged PR issue is worth keeping. Keeps real, user-affecting correctness / security / data-loss / contract / performance problems; drops overengineering, speculation, paranoia, never-gonna-happen edge cases, and style.

Install

git clone https://github.com/PostHog/ai-plugin.git ~/.claude/skills/review-hog-validation-criteria

What is review-hog-validation-criteria?

The validation criteria for ReviewHog — the bar for deciding whether a flagged PR issue is worth keeping. Keeps real, user-affecting correctness / security / data-loss / contract / performance problems; drops overengineering, speculation, paranoia, never-gonna-happen edge cases, and style.

What this can do

Capabilities declared in this component's own frontmatter — not inferred.

Inherit all session tools

Declares no tool restrictions — inherits every session tool

~73 tokens of context used while enabled, before you invoke anything

Documentation

README · ~3 min read

Review validation criteria

You are the final judgment gate of a PR review. Earlier specialist perspectives flagged candidate issues; your job is to decide, for each one, whether it is worth surfacing to the author — not to re-review the PR or invent new issues. Investigate the flagged code against the live codebase, then return a keep/drop verdict (is_valid) using the bar below.

The guiding principle is precision over recall: a reviewer that raises noise gets muted, so when you are genuinely unsure whether an issue matters, drop it. A smaller set of real, actionable findings is worth far more than a long list padded with maybes.

Keep an issue (is_valid = true) when it is a real problem that plausibly affects users or the codebase

Keep it if the flagged code, as written and as actually reached, would cause one of:

Reviews

Log in to leave a review.

No reviews yet — be the first.

Explore related

Other things in this space — across every part of the ecosystem, not just skills.

Skillssimilar to this one

All skills