AfterTool (write_file|replace) vs PreToolUse

Side by side on the facts. GitHub figures come straight from each repository; ratings come from signed-in reviewers here.

MetricAfterTool (write_file|replace)Hook PreToolUseHook

Type: AfterTool (write_file|replace)Hook; PreToolUseHook
Category: AfterTool (write_file|replace)Other; PreToolUseOther
GitHub stars: AfterTool (write_file|replace)0; PreToolUse0
Trust scoreⓘAuditability and maintenance signals — not a security audit.: AfterTool (write_file|replace)Not yet assessed; PreToolUseNot yet assessed
Community rating: AfterTool (write_file|replace)No reviews yet; PreToolUseNo reviews yet
Last commit: AfterTool (write_file|replace)Unknown; PreToolUseUnknown
Licence: AfterTool (write_file|replace)None declared; PreToolUseNone declared
Official: AfterTool (write_file|replace)No; PreToolUse Yes
Source: AfterTool (write_file|replace) Repository; PreToolUse Repository

Highlighted cells win that row on an objective measure. Rows without a clear winner — category, licence, source — are left unmarked. A higher trust score means better auditability and maintenance, not safer code.